Hello dear
Welcome to Casey's Eureka
At Casey's Eureka, passion for pizza meets a commitment to community. Nestled in the heart of Eureka, Illinois, we serve up delicious, made-to-order pizzas, crispy wings, and indulgent ice cream delights. Our dedicated staff, known for their warm hospitality, ensures every visit is memorable. With offerings like the peanut butter-infused "Happyness by the Pint" ice cream and customizable pizzas loaded with fresh ingredients, we cater to every craving. Emphasizing quality and service, Casey's Eureka is not just a restaurant; it’s a gathering place where flavors and friendships flourish, making every meal a joyful experience.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Marinara Sauce
Create Your Own Pizza
Nestle Tollhouse Vanilla Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich
Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough 16oz
About
Casey's Eureka
Welcome to Casey’s Eureka, the neighborhood gem located at 1801 S Main St, Eureka, IL 61530. Specializing in delicious pizza, this spot has quickly become a local favorite for both its mouthwatering offerings and its welcoming atmosphere. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted by a sense of warmth, courtesy of a dedicated team that genuinely cares about your dining experience.
One of the standout features of Casey’s Eureka is its impressive breakfast pizza selection. Start your day off right with options like our Bacon Breakfast Pizza, which showcases a rich cheese sauce or savory sausage gravy topped with fluffy scrambled eggs, crispy bacon, and a blend of mozzarella and cheddar cheese. For sausage lovers, the Sausage Breakfast Pizza takes the spotlight with a similar base that’s elevated by savory breakfast sausage. These pizzas are not just meals; they are a delightful way to kick-start your morning.
But the culinary delights don’t stop there. Casey’s Eureka also offers fresh sandwiches, such as the Ham & Swiss and Turkey & Cheddar 6-inch subs. Each is crafted with care, using quality ingredients that promise satisfying and delicious bites whether you're grabbing lunch on the go or enjoying a casual meal.
- Customer Favorites:
- Bacon Breakfast Pizza - A heartwarming start to any day!
- Sausage Breakfast Pizza - A savory twist for morning cravings.
- Ham & Swiss Sub - Perfectly balanced and hearty.
- Turkey & Cheddar Sub - A classic choice that's always delightful.
Customer reviews highlight the exceptional service at Casey’s Eureka. One loyal patron, Brian J., raves about the quality of the pizza, while Dave Stovall emphasizes the outstanding attitude of the staff, noting how they consistently provide prompt and friendly service. The dedication of the team is palpable; as Vernon VanWaters points out, even during busy times, the warmth and professionalism of the employees shine through, creating a welcoming environment for all who visit.
Whether you're looking for a quick breakfast fix or a casual dinner with friends, Casey’s Eureka promises not only hot and fresh food but also a friendly community vibe. I must say, after my visit, I couldn’t be happier with the experience. The flavors, the quality, and the service all combined make this a must-visit destination. Don’t forget to try their pizza subs—ask for extra sauce for a truly indulgent treat!
So next time you’re in Eureka, why not stop by and indulge in the delightful offerings at Casey’s Eureka? Your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Brooke makes the best pizza. Havent seen her there in a while, hopefully she didnt quit. Other than that, food is hot and fresh normally, you just have to go around the busy breakfastlunchdinner times. Otherwise, naturally, the cheese will on the pizza slices will be starting to dry out around 130200 up until dinner hour. Thats everywhere though. ”
“ As a professional,i will give 5 stars to this night crew through the week. They are amazing very polite nice young people I call ahead Im a truck February road. I call ahead for some chicken tenders. They are right on it and take care of it or if I want a big pizza its already when I get there. But just theyre Attitude is amazing amazing they need to be recognized they need to be recognized. They need to be recognized.attitude. Its really really good they need to be recognized. ”
“ Great employees and the store is very clean. I enjoy their Pizza as well. ”
“ We love Cathy and Virginia. We look forward to seeing them, when we come in. They handle their jobs in a very professional way. Even with being low staffed does not stop their customer service and hospitality. ”
“ Couldnt be happier. Everyone Ive encountered at this Caseys was friendly and helpful. They have had an issue with a nowformer employee a few months back I do remember it. Yet, being a loyal customer, Ive seen the improvements made and am quite pleased. Five stars all around, funniest cashiers anywhere. Also, order a pizza sub if youre willing to try it. Ask for extra pizza sauce, cheese, and whatever you like on your pizza. Its delicious, filling, and reasonably priced! ”
“ I love Caseys pizza. I have been to several in the last few days. The Caseys on the east side of Washington Illinois is fantastic. ”
“ They have good food you can grab and go. The place is clean and the staff were friendly to me. Recommend going here ”
“ Absolutely love Caseys... customer service is excellent ”